As a former insurance company defense lawyer, Michael knows how
insurance companies think & act when evaluating injury claims. Let us
use our inside knowledge to help you achieve maximum recovery.
Membership is limited to fewer than one percent (1%) of the nation's lawyers, and is based on peer reviews.
Deep Roots in the Pensacola Community
Mr. Fenimore was raised in Pensacola and has earned the trust and respect of local courtroom judges throughout his legal career.
Millions of Dollars Recovered For Clients
Since 2011, we have recovered millions of dollars for clients who were injured through the negligence of others across Northwest Florida.
Never a Fee, Unless We Win Your Case
We assume all the risk when you choose us to represent you. You will never pay us anything unless we win your case.
Pensacola Injury and Car Accident Lawyer
Dedicated to Accident and Injury Victims Across Pensacola Since 2011
At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we focus entirely on accident and injury cases. Our experience covers a wide range of matters, including car accidents, trucking collisions, motorcycle crashes, slip and fall incidents, wrongful death, brain injuries, medical malpractice, nursing home neglect, product defects, and more. If someone else's carelessness upended your life, we are here to help you fight for everything you are owed.
A serious accident can change the direction of your life in a single moment.
The physical pain, the mounting medical bills, the time away from work, and the uncertainty of what comes next can feel impossible to manage all at once. Then the legal process begins, and the pressure only grows. As your legal representative, we take that weight off your shoulders so you can concentrate on getting better while we handle the fight.
When the stakes are this high, you need an experienced Pensacola injury attorney who is genuinely in your corner.
Insurance companies move quickly after accidents. They reach out early, make fast settlement offers, and count on you not yet knowing the full value of your case before you sign anything. Your medical needs, lost wages, and pain and suffering can grow significantly over time, and a rushed settlement will not account for any of that. Having an experienced Pensacola injury and car accident lawyer on your side before you agree to anything gives you the information and leverage to make smart decisions. We provide a clear, honest assessment of your case so you understand exactly what it is worth and what it will take to get there.
"I hired Mr. Fenimore to represent me after I was involved in a car accident. He explained the process in a way I could completely understand. He worked diligently on my claim, guided me through the process, kept me updated on my case, and made me feel at ease. I highly recommend Michael..."
Jonah
Far exceeded my expectations
"Mr. Fenimore kept me informed and got me a result that far exceeded my expectations. Mr. Fenimore is a very personable attorney and he genuinely cares about his clients. I can't begin to thank him enough for his time and attention to my case. I wholeheartedly recommend him and his team!"
Jacky
High level of legal and professional competence
"He has always provided personal attention and handled my legal matters in a timely manner with outstanding results. I can attest to his high level of legal and professional competence. I give him my highest recommendation."
Jon
You Want Mr. Fenimore in Your Corner
"If you want an attorney who will take the time to explain things and walk you through the process, and not to mention get you a fantastic result (more than I ever thought possible), then you want Mr. Fenimore in your corner! There is no other attorney I would recommend!"
Diana
Made the Legal Process Easy
"Michael represented me in a motor vehicle accident. I was hospitalized and my vehicle was totaled. He made sure my expenses were completely covered and made the legal process as easy as I could've asked for. Highly recommend..."
C. Grace
Handled My Case Masterfully
"Mr. Fenimore handled my case masterfully. He worked diligently and efficiently to ensure my family's interests were protected and more importantly displayed genuine concern for our needs throughout the entire process. I give him my highest recommendation."
Since founding his own practice in 2011, Michael E. Fenimore has dedicated his career to representing people who have been seriously injured in car accidents, slip and falls, defective product cases, and a wide range of other accident and injury matters. His background in insurance defense gives him a distinct edge when negotiating and litigating against insurance companies on behalf of the people he represents. He knows exactly how insurers think, and he uses that knowledge to protect his clients.
"Getting our clients the full compensation they deserve is my top priority."
Mr. Fenimore is widely recognized as one of Northwest Florida's most tenacious and effective injury attorneys. He graduated with honors from the University of Florida and earned his Juris Doctor from Saint Louis University School of Law, where he was named a Dean's Scholar. He is a proud member of the Top American Lawyers, and his case results include millions recovered for injured clients throughout the region. He is admitted to practice in Florida and Missouri, and holds memberships in the American Bar Association, The Florida Bar, The Missouri Bar, and the Florida Justice Association as an Eagle Member.
Recovering the full compensation our clients are owed is the goal in every case we take on. Here are some of our results.
Auto Accident
Client was seriously injured in a rear-end car accident collision which necessitated shoulder surgery and multiple injective procedures in his neck and back.
$350k
OSHA Violations
Client who sustained catastrophic injuries which rendered him a complete paraplegic after falling from the roof of a home he was repairing.
$300k
Food-Related Injury
Case against a fast food restaurant where Plaintiff ingested numerous pieces of glass in his hamburger that the restaurant served him.
$475k
Auto Accident
At-fault driver suddenly and negligently made a right hand turn directly into the path of Mr. Fenimore's clients, t-boning his clients' vehicle at a high rate of speed.
$250k
Motorcycle Accident
Client was riding a motorcycle when the at-fault driver pulled out from an intersection directly in front of the client's approaching motorcycle.
$160k
Auto Accident
Client was rear-ended at an estimated 40 mph which caused a severe whiplash injury resulting in nerve root impingement in her lumbar spine.
A dedicated firm committed to giving every accident case the time and attention it deserves
Why Accident and Injury Victims in Pensacola Choose Fenimore Injury Law
Our attorneys work directly with accident and injury victims throughout the Pensacola area, providing focused, personalized legal representation built around your case and your recovery. We do not run a high-volume case mill. Every client works one-on-one with their attorney, and every matter gets the time, the strategy, and the urgency it requires.
Our practice is built on trial experience, sharp negotiation skills, and genuine concern for the people we represent. We take the time to fully understand how your accident has affected your work, your health, and your day-to-day life, so we can tell your story clearly and compellingly, whether that is across the table from an insurance adjuster or in front of a jury. Car accidents, motorcycle crashes, slip and falls, wrongful death claims, and more are all areas where we bring the same intensity and care.
What Sets Fenimore Injury Law Apart
Insurance-Defense Background That Works for You: Michael Fenimore spent years on the other side of these cases, representing insurance carriers and large corporations, before founding his own firm in 2011. That firsthand knowledge helps us spot insurer tactics early, challenge lowball offers before you accept them, and build your case for maximum value at the negotiating table or at trial when needed.
Proven Results and a Trial-Ready Mindset: We have recovered millions of dollars for accident and injury clients through smart negotiation and courtroom advocacy. Opposing counsel knows we are prepared to take a case all the way to verdict when that is what our client needs. That willingness consistently drives better and faster resolutions.
Direct Attorney Access, Not Case-Mill Treatment: You work with your attorney directly from the first call to the final resolution. We keep you informed at every stage, explain things in plain language, and do everything in our power to make the process as manageable as possible. It is why we have earned 70+ five-star client reviews praising our responsiveness, our compassion, and the results we achieve.
Local Roots with Panhandle-Wide Reach: Based in Pensacola, we serve clients throughout Escambia, Santa Rosa, and Okaloosa Counties and across the Florida Panhandle. When you cannot come to us, we will come to you. Evening and weekend appointments are available.
No Fee Unless We Win: We handle all accident and injury cases on a contingency fee basis. There are no attorney fees or case costs unless we recover compensation for you.
Credentials That Inspire Confidence: Michael is a member of Top American Lawyers (selection limited to fewer than 1% of attorneys nationwide), the American Bar Association, The Florida Bar, The Missouri Bar, the Florida Justice Association (Eagle Member), and the Escambia-Santa Rosa Bar Association.
Choose Fenimore Injury Law for experienced legal strategy, genuine care, and results that help you move forward. Call (850) 434-6064 or contact us today for a free, no-obligation consultation.
Resources for Accident and Injury Victims in Pensacola, Florida
Types of Compensation You May Be Entitled to After an Accident
Victims of serious accidents in Pensacola may be entitled to compensation that covers both financial losses and non-financial harm. These include medical expenses, lost income, future care costs, and compensation for pain and suffering. When an injury results in permanent disability or lasting emotional trauma, the value of your claim can increase substantially.
Additional damages may include loss of earning capacity, ongoing rehabilitation costs, and, in cases involving married victims, loss of consortium for the spouse. Every accident case is different, and our team carefully evaluates all aspects of your situation to make sure every available form of compensation is identified and pursued.
How the Value of an Accident or Injury Claim Is Determined
The value of your claim depends on several factors, including the severity of your injuries, how they affect your life going forward, and how clearly fault can be established. Some of the key considerations include:
The severity and permanence of your injuries
Your need for long-term medical care or assistive equipment
How long your recovery takes and how much work you miss as a result
The degree of pain, suffering, and emotional distress involved
Loss of enjoyment of life or ability to carry out normal daily activities
Available insurance coverage and the strength of the liability evidence
Insurance companies routinely try to undervalue accident claims. At Fenimore Injury Law, we fight to make sure your compensation reflects the full scope of your losses, now and in the future.
Steps to Take After a Serious Accident or Injury
The actions you take in the hours and days after an accident can have a major impact on the strength of your case. Here is what we recommend:
Seek medical attention right away, even if your injuries feel minor at first.
Document everything you can: photos of injuries, the accident scene, vehicle damage, and any other relevant details.
Keep records of all medical visits, treatments, and related expenses.
Do not give a recorded statement to the other party's insurance company before speaking with a lawyer.
Contact an experienced Pensacola injury attorney as soon as possible to protect your rights and preserve your options.
If you are not sure what your next step should be, that is exactly what we are here for. Reach out to our office and we will walk you through everything from the very first call.
Talk to an Experienced Pensacola Injury and Car Accident Attorney Today
If you or a loved one has been seriously hurt in an accident caused by someone else's negligence, do not wait. Contact Michael E. Fenimore, P.A. at (850) 434-6064 or fill out our online form to schedule a free, no-obligation consultation. We offer flexible appointment times and can travel to meet you when needed. There are no upfront fees. We only get paid if we recover compensation for you.
Other Locations We Serve
Accident and injury representation throughout Northwest Florida
