As a former insurance defense lawyer, Michael knows how insurance companies think & act when evaluating car accident claims. Let us help you by using our inside knowledge to help you achieve a maximum recovery.
Membership is limited to fewer than one percent (1%) of the nation’s lawyers, and is based on peer reviews.
Relationships With Our Local Judges
Mr. Fenimore was raised in Pensacola, and has the much needed relationships and respect of our local courtroom judges.
Millions of Dollars Recovered For Clients
Since 2011, we have recovered millions of dollars for our clients in resulting from the negligence of others.
Never a Fee, Unless We Win Your Case
We assume all the risk when you choose us to represent you. You will never pay us anything unless we win your case.
Pensacola Car Accident Lawyer
Proudly Fighting For Auto Accident Victims Since 2011
We are fully committed to handling car accident cases with dedication and determination. Our clients are our highest priority in every auto accident case we take on. At Michael E. Fenimore, we understand the importance of excellent legal representation and are deeply invested in the well-being of each individual and their unique circumstances.
Our firm recognizes that experiencing a car accident can significantly impact a person’s quality of life and shape their future.
The legal challenges that arise from these situations often add extra stress and anxiety for accident victims. As your legal representative, we will tenaciously advocate for you and ensure that your experience with the legal process is efficient and free from unnecessary stress or complications.
During these difficult times, you need legal counsel and representation you can depend on. Time is of the essence.
In Pensacola, FL, motor vehicle accidents—such as those involving cars, motorcycles, semi-trucks, bicycles, and boats—are among the most common personal injury cases. If you’ve been injured in a car accident, you may be feeling overwhelmed by mounting medical bills, lost wages from missed work, and the inability to cover repair costs for your vehicle. Car accidents can be not only physically devastating, resulting in life-altering injuries, but also financially burdensome. Families often face the stress of pressure from the other driver’s insurance company to accept a low settlement offer, when the primary focus should be on recovering and getting back to work and normal life.
"I hired Mr. Fenimore to represent me after I was involved in a car accident. He explained the process in a way I could completely understand. He worked diligently on my claim, guided me through the process, kept me updated on my case, and made me feel at ease. I highly recommend Michael..."
Jonah
Far exceeded my expectations
"Mr. Fenimore kept me informed and got me a result that far exceeded my expectations. Mr. Fenimore is a very personable attorney and he genuinely cares about his clients. I can’t begin to thank him enough for his time and attention to my case. I wholeheartedly recommend him and his team!"
Jacky
High level of legal and professional competence.
"He has always provided personal attention and handled my legal matters in a timely manner with outstanding results. I can attest to his high level of legal and professional competence. I give him my highest recommendation."
Jon
You Want Mr. Fenimore in Your Corner
"If you want an attorney who will take the time to explain things and walk you through the process, and not to mention get you a fantastic result (more than I ever thought possible), then you want Mr. Fenimore in your corner! There is no other attorney I would recommend!"
Diana
Made the Legal Process Easy
"Michael represented me in a motor vehicle accident. I was hospitalized and my vehicle was totaled. He made sure my expenses were completely covered and made the legal process as easy as I could’ve asked for. Highly recommend..."
C. Grace
Handled My Case Masterfully
"Mr. Fenimore handled my case masterfully. He worked diligently and efficiently to ensure my family’s interests were protected and more importantly displayed genuine concern for our needs throughout the entire process. I give him my highest recommendation."
Since 2011, Mr. Fenimore has used his superior experience in the insurance defense industry to exclusively represent individuals who have been injured in automobile accidents, slip and falls, product defect cases, and other cases involving serious accidents and injuries.
"Getting our clients the full compensation for their injuries is my top priority."
After founding his own law firm, Michael quickly developed a reputation as one of the most aggressive and successful personal injury attorneys in Northwest Florida. His credentials include graduating with honors from the University of Florida, receiving his law degree from Saint Louis University School of Law where he earned Dean’s Scholar distinction, being honored as a member of Top American Lawyers, recovering millions of dollars for clients, and being a member of the American Bar Association, The Florida Bar, The Missouri Bar, and an Eagle Member of the Florida Justice Association.
Getting our clients the full compensation for their injuries is our top priority. See some of our results below.
Car Accident
Client was seriously injured in a rear-end car accident collision which necessitated shoulder surgery and multiple injective procedures in his neck and back.
$350k
Serious Auto Accident
Client was seriously injured in a car accident which required surgery on her lower back, radiofrequency ablations, and stem cell procedures in order to help her overcome her injuries.
$250k
Rear End Collision
Client was rear-ended at an estimated 40 mph which caused a severe whiplash injury resulting in nerve root impingement in her lumbar spine.
$200k
T-Bone Accident
At-fault driver suddenly and negligently made a right hand turn directly into the path of Mr. Fenimore’s clients, t-boning his clients’ vehicle at a high rate of speed.
$250k
Auto Accident
The at-fault driver negligently ran a stop sign and made a left hand turn directly into the path of my clients’ oncoming vehicle, causing a violent t-bone collision.
$200k
Uninsured Motorist
Client suffered serious injuries when an uninsured motorist ran a stop sign and t-boned my him at more than 35 mph.
A dedicated firm focused on giving every case the personalized attention it deserves.
Why Choose Fenimore Injury Law
Accidents in and around Pensacola are a leading cause of property damage, injury, and fatalities each year. According to the
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA),
traffic crashes remain a significant public safety concern nationwide. Motor vehicle accidents make up the majority of our firm’s cases. We promptly dedicate resources to investigating the accident, collecting evidence, photographing the damage, and identifying witnesses. Most importantly, we thoroughly examine the involved insurance companies to ensure our clients receive the full benefits of all available coverage for their auto accident claims. Having an experienced attorney on your side can greatly impact the outcome of your case.
With a background in insurance defense dating back to 2011, Mr. Fenimore brings invaluable insight and experience to every case he handles. His deep understanding of insurance company tactics allows our firm to effectively advocate for accident victims, ensuring that clients receive the full compensation they deserve for injuries from auto accidents, slip and falls, product defects, and other serious incidents.
Our Pensacola car accident attorneys are experienced in managing all types of auto accident cases and have a deep understanding of how insurance companies operate.
We Work On a Contingency Fee Basis
Typically, lawyers charge a lump sum fee, which may require an upfront payment of a specified percentage, with additional payments due at key milestones. However, car accident specialists often work on a contingency fee basis. At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we offer completely free, confidential consultations, and if you choose to hire us, you won’t owe us anything unless you receive satisfactory compensation.
How Our Pensacola Car Accident Lawyers Will Maximize Your Auto Accident Claim
As soon as you hire us, we will begin taking the necessary steps to substantiate your claim and protect you from any tactics the insurance company may use to take advantage of you:
We will assist you in obtaining the necessary medical treatment by connecting you with qualified practitioners that fit your budget. If needed, we can also refer you to our healthcare partners who may provide treatment on a lien basis.
Our team will investigate the details of the accident to determine how it happened and who was at fault. This will involve visiting the accident scene, capturing photos and videos, interviewing witnesses, and reviewing police or fire reports.
We will consult with experts to reconstruct the accident, analyzing the speed and movement of vehicles as well as the actions of each driver.
On your behalf, we will identify and reach out to the relevant insurance companies to establish and negotiate your compensation claim.
We will engage expert witnesses to testify on your behalf.
If we are unable to secure a satisfactory settlement with the insurance company, we are fully prepared to file a lawsuit and advocate vigorously for your rights.
Maximize Your Case with Our Pensacola Car Accident Lawyers
If you or a loved one has been injured in a car accident, reach out to Michael E. Fenimore, P.A. at (850) 434-6064 to discuss your case. If you can’t make it to our office, we are happy to travel to you. You can also fill out our contact form at the bottom of this page. We offer evening and weekend appointments for your convenience. We provide a free, no-obligation consultation for all personal injury cases, and you won’t owe us any fees unless we secure compensation for your injuries.
Resources for Car Accident Victims in Pensacola, Florida
Types of Compensation You Can Recover
The compensation or damages you can recover in a car accident claim or lawsuit in Pensacola primarily depends on the losses you have incurred. The purpose of these damages is to reimburse you for your expenses and financial losses, as well as to compensate for non-financial losses. Potential recoverable damages include reimbursement for medical expenses, lost wages, and any out-of-pocket costs. Additionally, you may be eligible for damages related to loss of earning capacity, mental anguish, and pain and suffering.
If you were married at the time of the accident, your spouse may be eligible to claim damages for loss of consortium. This refers to the loss of services, support, companionship, and assistance that you would have provided to your spouse if the accident had not occurred.
How Much Your Car Accident Case Is Worth
Determining the worth of a car accident claim in Pensacola can be challenging. This is due to the various factors involved in the claims process—and potentially a trial—that can influence the value of your case. Generally, the value of a claim primarily depends on the specific circumstances of the incident and the losses you have experienced. Some of these factors include:
The extent of your injuries: Claims involving serious injuries, such as spinal fractures, traumatic brain injuries, or fatalities, often settle for significant amounts.
The potential for permanent disability, long-term temporary disability, or scarring.
The duration required for your full recovery and return to work.
The total cost of your medical bills, including any future treatment.
Pain, suffering, and emotional distress experienced as a result of the accident.
The severity of the other party’s actions that led to the accident. Recklessness, intentional harm, and negligence can increase the value of a claim.
You might be tempted to accept a low settlement offer from the other driver’s insurance company just to get through this challenging period. The insurance company aims to have you accept the lowest settlement possible to resolve the case as quickly as they can.
These settlement offers often fall short of covering all your medical bills, vehicle repair costs, and lost wages resulting from the accident. If you’ve been pressured to accept a low settlement by an aggressive insurance adjuster, reach out to our experienced Pensacola car accident attorneys today. We will take a firm stance against the other driver’s insurance company to ensure you receive the full compensation you deserve for your injuries.
How Long You Have to File Your Claim
In Pensacola car accident claims, timely action is crucial. Delaying contact with a car accident lawyer in Pensacola can negatively impact your claim. Florida's statute of limitations mandates that victims file a claim within a specific timeframe. For car accidents, this period is two years from the date of the accident.
If you fail to file your claim within this timeframe, you will be barred from filing a lawsuit. This means your case will be considered time-barred and cannot be brought to court. Consequently, no insurance company will consider a time-barred claim, let alone provide compensation.
Steps to Take After The Car Accident
If you or someone around you is capable, you should also try to take the following steps:
Collect the details of the other drivers involved in the accident. Get their name, contact information, insurance number, as well as the name and contact information of all passengers in their vehicle.
Write down the details of all other vehicles involved in the accident. Useful information includes make, model, year and license tag number.
Be sure to note anything the other driver and passengers say. This may help indicate where the fault lies for the accident. For example, record comments like “I’m so sorry”, “I didn’t see you”, “I was in a hurry” etc.
Get the names and contact information of witnesses to the accident. They will be vital to help establish the circumstances of the accident. If you can, take photos and video of the accident scene as well, and all vehicles involved.
After you visit the doctor, make a list of all your personal injuries. Also keep a list of all your doctor and hospital visits, and other medical expenses. They will be useful to show what the accident has cost you.
Contact your insurance company as soon as possible to report the accident. Ideally, you should call once your health and that of those around you are secure.
In the aftermath of a car accident, it is normal to feel confused, angry or frustrated. You should understand however, that your actions in the aftermath of the accident could make or break your case. The first thing you should do after the accident is to get help, especially if you or anyone else has sustained an injury. Call 911 to get law enforcement and emergency services to the scene. Your health and safety are of primary importance.
First, ensure your safety by moving out of traffic on busy roads like Highway 98. Call 911 to report the accident and seek medical attention, even if you feel fine. Avoid speaking with insurance adjusters without consulting a lawyer. At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we can guide you through these critical steps to protect your rights.
In Florida, the statute of limitations for most car accident claims is four years from the date of the accident, as of 2025. However, certain factors, like injuries discovered later, may affect this timeline. Contacting a Pensacola car accident lawyer promptly ensures you don’t miss critical deadlines. Learn more.
Florida follows a comparative negligence system, meaning fault can be shared between parties. We investigate your accident using police reports, witness statements, and other evidence to prove the other driver’s liability. Our experience in Pensacola courts helps us build a strong case for you. Learn more.
You may be entitled to compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, property damage, and future care costs. At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we use our 20+ years of experience to calculate and fight for the full compensation you deserve. Learn more.
Car accident cases involve complex laws, insurance negotiations, and local court procedures. As a local Pensacola firm, we know the courts, judges, and insurers in Escambia County. Our proven track record ensures you get the best possible outcome without the stress of navigating the system alone.
Having defended insurance companies, I understand their tactics to minimize payouts. At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we use this insider knowledge to anticipate their strategies, negotiate effectively, and secure the settlement you deserve.
Florida law allows you to seek compensation through your uninsured motorist coverage if the other driver lacks insurance. We can also explore other options, like pursuing the at-fault driver’s personal assets. Our team will explore every avenue to get you compensated.
At Michael E. Fenimore, P.A., we work on a contingency fee basis. This means you pay nothing upfront, and we only get paid if we win your case. Our goal is to make legal help accessible while fighting for your best interests.
The timeline varies depending on the case. Simple settlements may take a few months, while cases that go to trial can take a year or more. Factors like injury severity and insurance disputes play a role. We’ll keep you informed every step of the way.
Yes, Florida’s comparative negligence law allows you to recover damages even if you were partially at fault. Your compensation will be reduced by your percentage of fault. We work to minimize your liability and maximize your recovery.
Most car accident cases settle out of court, but we prepare every case as if it will go to trial. With our experience in Escambia County courts, we’re ready to fight for you in the courtroom if necessary.
A valid claim typically involves proving the other driver’s negligence caused your injuries and damages. We offer a free consultation to review your case, explain your rights, and determine the best path forward.
Have more questions? Contact us for a free consultation with a trusted Pensacola car accident lawyer.
